Niiiiiice......

Great Stuff!

I don't see why everyone's rated this battle so highly. While it is well made and has a decent plot, it really really sucks. In each mission you face no less than 10 waves of each type of craft, coming at you in flights of 4-6 each. The missions are insane because of this and quite frustrating. Trying to defent your command ship from a total of 36 torpedo armed Y-Wings in waves of 6, while fighting off 60 or so missile armed X-Wings and R-41s in waves of 4 is enough to make me want to break something. PLEASE!! Make good battles, make nice battles, but before all else, make REALISTIC battles.

Overall a rather dull battle. Though bug and flaw free, it is essentially the same mission over and over again, and the lack of craft variety (namely no T/Bs or GUNs) makes the missions frustrating as most involve some sort of capital ship attack. Being stuck in a shieldless T/I for 3 of 4 missions is boreing.

Dispite being a little on the crazy side, this mission is actually pretty fun. Plus, using only the basic T/F harkens to days of old. :)

Excellent battle overall, one of the best I've played in a while, challenging!

Nice set of missions, seems to be bug free... most enjoyable.

A quick mission that is fairly easy and bug free. Excellent for comps.

Again, this is one of those battles that should be about half the length it is. While the missions target different things, the goals are the same. Also, the lack of "realism" in this battle really got on my nerves. Obvious things like using T/Is to attack captial ships and only deploying a handful of fighters to defend an ISD under attack are errors that really detract from the enjoyability of this battle. While the missions are glitch free, I was just about sick of flying it by the time I got to the end.

This battle is the most repetitive one I've ever seen done. The plot just drags on and on, it could have really been done well in about 5 missions instead of the 12 that there are. On the brighter side... the battle is free of any technical problems, and offers a wide variety of craft and armament selection for most of the missions.

This is one of the wierdest battles I have ever flown. It has a plot... which makes no sense. Ships that are supposed to be "critical craft" get blown away and nothing happens, craft fly into eachother, and the K-Wings, while amusing, are a totally pointless additon to the battle. I can understand making a battle to use a new patch... but please make something with a realistic plot next time.

Absolutely awesome... by far the most realistic mission I have ever played. Good strategy combined with capital ship interaction places this mission on another level altogether. Why dosen't the EH have more missions like this one?

I don't understand why everyone rated this battle so highly. The missions were mediocre at best, and the nice little flaw in mission four of friendly TIE Bombers turning on their own command ship makes getting any of the bonus objectives nearly impossible. This battle is far from the awesomeness needed to actually rate a 5. It is playable, and beatable, but it wasn't that much fun.

An excellent battle, with a good storyline and lots of action to back it up. If you like big fleet engagements, this is the battle to fly.

Absloutely amazing!! and hillarious to boot!! Great plotline, good action, and the tugs are definately challenging. If you are looking for a good, interesting battle with loads of laughs, play this one!!

Overall this is a poor mission... The objectives are reasonable, and the environemt is full of targets that you'd love to shoot (plenty of cap. ships, and a big shipyard). IF you could get the three squadrons of fighters off your tail long enough to do so!! The other "friendly" fighters and cap. ships do absolutely nothing to help you, so you are left to deal with over 36 fighters, by yourself. Great if you like dogfighting, but horrible if you'd rather kill cap. ships. If you turn your decoy beam system on to free yourself of the enemy fighters, they simply run to hyperspace, and take their bonus points with them. So, by the time you take care of the enemy fighters, all the other "big" targets have been destroyed, leaving you with a pitiful score to show for all the work you did. Then there is the matter of the Traitor, his shuttle is set on invulnerable (something I despise). So you can't get to him as early as you should be able to and have to do things the hard way. In conclusion, this mission has the beginnings of a good one, but it needs major revision before it can be considered playable and realistic (wingmen that actually help you would be a BIG PLUS).

Definately one of the more "different" battles that I've played. It would have been alot better with T/Ds instead of Guardians, and I never did understand the point of having shieldless T/As. The one mission where you take out the rebel platform is crazy. They launch 5-6 squadrons of fighters at you, and while the fighters aren't hard to kill... it just gets old after a while. The capital ships also need reworking, so they don't fly into one another. Overall I've seen better, but I've also seen worse. I'd give it a 2.5 if I could.

One of the best battles I have ever played. A great storyline, combined with excellent briefings and fast paced action. Definately worth a 5!!

A most excellent battle, if not the best I've ever played. The storyline was great and the missions were challenging while not being impossible. I would have given it a 5 but I found a bug in mission two that made me unable to complete the mission, so I had to skip it. Overall a most impressive battle, I think everyone should fly it.

Good storyline; the missions are a bit on the easy side I must admit, and the last one has some confusing objectives. Dispite this it is one of the highest quality battles I have played.